Kevin Costner is tossing out hints about a return to the TV show Yellowstone like it’s

a game of hot potato, leaving viewers spinning in confusion.

In the world of television, the only constant is change. That’s been truer than ever for the

hit Western series Yellowstone lately. It’s like trying to catch a greased pig at a county fair;

just when you think you’ve got a handle on the situation, it slips right through your fingers.

Recently, fans have had to become veritable detectives, picking up on every subtle hint and cryptic comment to speculate about the show’s future. And speaking of mysteries, Kevin Costner—our modern-day cowboy king—has certainly kept everyone on their toes. Despite confirming he would not be returning for Yellowstone Season 5B in November, the actor hasn’t entirely ruled out making a comeback to the ranch.

Kevin Costner’s Yellowstone Tease: Will He or Won’t He?

In that case, you might as well shout it from the rooftops! The beloved Western Yellowstone has always had more twists and turns than a cowboy on a bucking bronco, and lately, fans have been left deciphering the cryptic clues dropped by Kevin Costner himself.

Recently, while chatting with ET, he described the show as “a wonderful part of my life,” adding:

Who knows, some things have a way of circling back. I haven’t seen that dust trail coming toward me, but I’ve always been open to what I started. Five seasons was a lot for us to do, and I think that story is not finished.

So, what does this mean for our favorite ranching drama? Well, while Costner has confirmed he won’t be riding back into the sunset for Season 5B, he left the door wide open for a future appearance. He even suggested that the story could continue through the younger Duttons, saying:

Make the story about them.

Now, let’s not forget that this isn’t the first time fans have been on a wild ride with Costner’s commitments. He first announced he’d be stepping away from Yellowstone in spring 2023, stirring the pot with rumors of behind-the-scenes drama and scheduling conflicts.

While he has officially said goodbye on social media, he’s left the window cracked just enough to let in a breeze. He mentioned that he’d be open to donning the cowboy hat again “under the right circumstances,” during a promo for his film Horizon: An American Saga (via Today). So, there’s still hope for those longing glances at the ranch!