In a dramatic twist on Emmerdale, fans are convinced that John Sugden is weaving a web of lies about his true

identity, particularly regarding the newcomer Aidan Moore. John, played by Oliver Farnworth, made a splash

when he was revealed to be the long-lost son of Jack Sugden, portrayed by Clive Hornby. His arrival has stirred

significant intrigue in the village, especially for Victoria Sugden, who recently discovered she has an unknown brother.

Tensions escalated when Victoria, driven by her curiosity, searched through John’s van—his former home—and stumbled upon dog tags with the name Aidan Moore. Caught in the act, John reacted angrily, demanding she stay out of his affairs. However, he later apologized and shared a poignant story about Aidan, claiming he was his closest comrade during their service in Afghanistan. John recounted a heartbreaking memory of playing football with a local boy before Aidan was tragically killed in a bombing.

Despite John’s emotional tale, fans remain skeptical. Many have taken to social media to voice their doubts about his authenticity. Comments on an Emmerdale fan page suggest that viewers suspect John may be using Aidan’s identity for his own purposes, with one fan speculating that the real John Sugden could be the army mate instead.

As the storyline unfolds, the question remains: Is John really who he claims to be, or is there a hidden truth lurking beneath the surface? Stay tuned for more thrilling developments in Emmerdale!